This one was the closest to the original feel of the pulps. Lots of great action and hair-raising escapes. It is longer though which I find detracts from my enjoyment for some reason and the more clear-cut characterizations throws me as well. All in all a very good Doc Savage adventure. Hopefully Will Murray will one day be able to write more Docs.
- | - May 6, 2003 02:08 PM
I give it a B+... pretty good job for a new version of a Doc Savage adventure, but it just can't compare to the originals. I read this book because I heard it was pretty good, but even though I give it a B+, I still think they should have just stuck with the original series... and left it at that. Sometimes MORE is not necessarily better. Actually, what bugs me the most about these new books is the artwork on the back cover... Doc looks more or less o.k. but his 5 associates look virtually the same as each other. Even monk is not at all "homely" or "apish" looking. On the old bantams, each character had a unique look which made it impossible to confuse them. In the new renderings, it took me ten minutes to distinguish Ham from Long Tom, or LOng Tom from Renny for that matter. I know this is a minor complaint... but it just reinforces my point that they should have left well enough alone and ended it all with the original Doc Series.
- | - July 14, 2003 07:14 PM