Doc Savage Org Logo
 

features   Featuring   features Pulp   Pulps   Pulp Bantam   Bantam   Bantam Authors   Authors   Authors Editors   Editors   Editors Illustrators   Illus.   Illustrators Links   The Fans   Links Comments   133   Comments search
 
« 118b 12/41 Peril in the North - | - 141f 02/42 Men of Fear »

column 133d 01/42 The Rustling Death column
 

4201.jpg


A powerful weapon of destruction has been unleashed -- a device which can disintegrate the defenseless population. Can Doc and his crew save their country -- or will this tool of doom become a madman's terrifying toy?




Categories:

1942 - 1942
b133 - b133
clark - clark
hathway - hathway
larkin - larkin
nanovic - nanovic
novel - novel
pulp - pulp
   
   
column Comments  column
 

omni02.jpg


Note: Comments may contain spoilers.

Scott Kimball

While many readers would chose Laurence Donovan as the worst ghost writer, for me, Alan Hathway takes top honors in that category. As I have mentioned in another post, I agree that Donovan deserves all the criticism he gets..but he is also incredibly entertaining to read. Sure, his ramblings seem to have no relation whatsoever to any physical reality or any sort of existential paradigm that usually, in some way, governs the experience and perceptions of any so-called "normal" person, but his stories are absolutely fascinating and hilarious. Alan Hathway, on the other hand is so flat, lifeless, and boring that I barely made it through THE MINDLESS MONSTERS, and I actually could not even finish THE RUSTLING DEATH. I tried, but I could only make it about 3/4 of the way through... reading this book was like a grueling 20 mile bicycle ride up a mountain pass, I got about 15 miles into it before realizing that it just wasn't fun anymore. It is strange, because there are moments, paragraphs, where Hathway really shines. The problem is that those paragraphs are about 20 or 30 pages apart. While reading his books, I had the sensation of staring at a flat grey concrete wall from about 12 inches away, hoping it might somehow get interesting after a while... well, it never really does, at least not enough to overcome my short attention span. Thumbs way down on this one. When you know in the first chapter that the Mystery is just some machine, you can tell it is going to suck... and this one is no exception. I could go on, but I won't bore you any longer... the RUSTLING DEATH does a better job of it anyway.

- | - September 14, 2003 03:23 AM


   
   

editors Post a Comment editors
 
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Note: Your email and URL will not be published.





Keep Info?



Please note: DocSavage.Org will never republish any comments for profit. We retain the right to edit or delete any comments. We also retain the right to reformat this site and any comments. By submitting your comment you agree to these conditions.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
   
   

Design adapted by: Chuck Welch and powered by Moveable Type
Send comments to: ds AT this domain

Patience and beauty by Catherine Lavallée-Welch

Thanks to Duane Spurlock at the Pulp Rack and Steve Sherman for their Bronzetoe help and inspiration.

Thanks to Chris Kalb and the 86th Floor for help and inspiration.

Doc Savage Org is a member of the Doc Savage Webring
<< Prev | Next >> | [ Random | Ring Hub | Join Us! ]


This page last updated at January 21, 2006 03:51 PM.

All copyrighted characters, names, and art depicted on this site are copyrighted by their various respective owners.

Doc Savage is (c) by Conde Nast
Bantam Scans donated by David Schneider.

DocSavage.Org is (c) 2004 by Chuck Welch Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.