Run of the mill Doc tale, though still enjoyable. Remarkable as yet another example of Dent's vast knowledge of geographical region-specific information.
- | - July 22, 2003 02:31 PM
I agree with what was said above, especially about Dent. While this tale is average (for a Doc adventure) we find yet again a dazzling display of Dent's unique ability to capture locations and peoples. His grasp of cultural nuances and regional geography is almost uncanny. He always seems to know everything about the soil, trees, lakes, rivers, and animals of any given area, and then weave amongst the hell-bent-for-leather razor's edge of action some very in-depth snapshots of indigenous peoples' histories and ways of life, including language, clothing, music, art, and, of course, warfare. He is always several steps ahead of the readers and creates very real, living, breathing expansive worlds for his adventure stories. In this way, he's a cross between the epic high action, full-blooded passion of Homer and the deep, reflective, naturalist wisdom of a Thoreau.
One might say Dent's amazing skill as a storyteller and finely tuned balance of coldly calculating scientific knowledge with fluid native intuition borders on being Doc Savage-ish.
Thomas Fortenberry
- | - August 14, 2003 11:29 PM
I don't think this is a Dent story (Hathaway might have ghosted it). But, it's still a pretty good story that is very rich in detail and descriptive writing (this is why it doesn't strike me as a Dent story). I found the torture scene with Monk very well written and Monk never seemed to come across so powerfully as in this book. One complaint was the canoe suddenly becoming a two-man submarine. Still, it's a good read if a bit implausible and not quite the Doc Savage we're familiar with. As for the Bama cover, I was wondering if it looks better in its original form. Bama is/was a masterful painter of both cowboys and Indians. I think this painting has all sorts of details Bantam either leaves out or blurs. (This happened to the cover to The Fantastic Island, supposedly one of Bama's personal favorites.)
- | - March 7, 2005 07:56 PM