
Note: Comments may contain spoilers. Chuck Welch
Now this was a villan I want to see again. The McGuffin was silly, but the rest of the novel read well and kept me wanting to read the next chapter. The "Bad Baldwins" and their brothers in crime made for memorable "Second Tier Bad Guys". - | - September 6, 2002 11:23 PM
Duane Spurlock
Nice action throughout. I liked that the villains were known throughout the story -- a nice change of pace from the default formula shtick of the villain posing as an innocent and hanging out with Doc and crew. And the villain -- Cadwiller Olden -- posed a true threat to Doc and gang, instead of being an eccentric-appearing bad guy with no bite to back up his bark, as sometimes happens with Dent villains. That Doc was aware of Olden's background from the start lends credence to the claims that Doc keeps an eye out on bad guys globally thanks to his network of agents -- since readers rarely see these agents, the whole network of Doc's influence often seems sort of nebulous. Excellent saga! - | - November 5, 2002 04:05 PM
Andrew Salmon
This one was like a breath of fresh air after the disappointing Escape From Loki. Great villain! Great action! One of the best Docs I've read so far. I'd like to see more of this deadly dwarf. Don't let the Bantam title of this one fool you. The dward IS deadly. Great stuff! - | - March 12, 2003 03:12 PM
Dennis Kesler
I recently bought this pulp. I did because I think this is one of the finest that was done for the pulps.
Doc looks like a spaceman in his futuristic diving suit. There are so many wonderful pulp covers, but this is my favorite. - | - May 19, 2004 02:02 PM
Paul Cook
This has the best pulp cover of any Doc Savage, as far as I'm concerned. It captures the essence of Doc's daring and his scientific accumen. As for the story, I think it was partially ghosted because of the rapidity with which it starts. I think it starts at chapter 2 or 3 of an earlier manuscript, or that the first chapters are squeezed into the new opening chapter. But this is a good Doc Savage novel with a unique conceit. I only wish Bantam had had the courage to keep its title at "Repel" (the same way they should have kept the title for "Ost"). Otherwise, a fairly good read with a very memorable villain. - | - March 7, 2005 08:02 PM
Mark Carpenter
Yes, "The Deadly Dwarf" is rip-roaring fun. But what knocked me over was Dent's not-so-subtle description of Cadwiller Olden's
... um... personal proclivities. Surrounding himself with shirtless musclemen? Painting his toenails? Hmmm. I bet this was tough to get through an editor in 1937. But all that aside, the story is a barnburner and shows that even the most brilliant and organized criminals are no match for Doc. - | - July 10, 2005 09:13 AM
Heather O'Neill
My all time fav. I loved the villian, the Bad Baldwins,eapecially the part were they reveal that Doc sent him to his crime collage and got them to spy on the bad guy. The plot was great and the part were Jonny almost reveals that they are on the island when he almost gets hit by a lava rock, especially the way he convinces the reporter that he is not a man of much learning. All in all a book I could, and have many times, read in one hour I just can't put this one down. - | - March 27, 2006 04:01 AM
|