Doc Savage Org Logo
 

features   Featuring   features Pulp   Pulps   Pulp Bantam   Bantam   Bantam Authors   Authors   Authors Editors   Editors   Editors Illustrators   Illus.   Illustrators Links   The Fans   Links Comments   036   Comments search
 
« 077 10/36 The South Pole Terror - | - 052 12/36 The Vanisher »

column 036 11/36 Resurrection Day column
 

3611.jpg


The sweeping genius of the Man of Bronze reaches into the very secret of life itself. A stunned nation hears the announcement that one -- and only one -- long-dead human being will be brought back to life. Who will be chosen? Lincoln? Edison? Shakespeare? As the world rejoices and conjectures, the powers of Evil plan a final, insidious joke on all humanity!




Categories:

1936 - 1936
B025 - B025
Bama - Bama
Harris - Harris
Nanovic - Nanovic
novel - novel
pulp - pulp
   
   
column Comments  column
 

036.jpg


Note: Comments may contain spoilers.

Andrew Salmon

I liked this one though it isn't one of my favourites. The story is way over the top with Doc developing a serum to bring back the dead! Yikes! But the moral dilemma Doc goes through trying to decide WHO to bring back was interesting but it's kind of downhill from there. Some good action though but the moral question is the heart of this story.

- | - July 22, 2003 05:50 PM

Todd Pence

Okay . . . the novel itself is pretty good Doc, as far as writing and plotting are considered. The problem, of course, comes from the central premise, which surely has to be regarded as the most preposterous, nay ridiculous, of any Doc Savage novel (with the possible exception of "Up From Earth's Center".) Subterrenean civilizations, invisibility formulas, matter transportation machines, mind reading devices . . . all of these I can accept in order to enjoy a Doc story. But Doc restoring life to a body that has been dead for centuries? Hoo boy, this one is a little too big to swallow.
Further handicapping this idea is the historical individual Doc chooses to resurrect. Doc is looking to bring back someone to life who would be a benefit to humanity. He apparently can choose from any figure in history, and he chooses . . . King Solomon?!?!? In the first place, it is questionable whether a man brought back from Solomon's time after living a lifetime in that era would be able to even function in the modern society of the twentieth century, much less give any kind of aid or benefit to that society. A man from those times would find themselves overwhelmed by a completely alien way of life and moral standards and would be just as likely to end up in an insane asylum as in a position of leadership. In addition, the Bible portrays Solomon as a vengeful, jealous and murderous tyrant, hardly the sort of philanthropic and wise spirit Doc is looking for. I'm surprised at Doc for making such a questionable choice for the person to be resurrected.
Furthermore, the premise of the novel opens up a whole area of philosophical speculation (i.e. what impact would being able to raise a dead man back to life have upon society and our way of life?), but being a Doc Savage novel, it chooses only to follow the action/adventure part of the premise and leave the more cerebral part unadressed. Dent was an inventive, but not much of a speculative writer, and so he may have tackled a subject to big for him here and revelaed a limitation of the Doc Savage series as a whole. There is no indication that I could find in this novel that Doc couldn't repeat the resurrection process again (all that is said about it is that the chemicals involved in the process are "extremely rare"), and so I think Dent opened a can of worms he was not ready to fully handle. I think Dent was saying to himself at this point "What can I do to make Doc even more of a superman? Ah, I know! I'll have him be able to restore the dead!" Maybe Dent learned his lesson from this novel, for he never again tries to give Doc such godlike powers, and in later years tried to downplay Doc's superhuman aspects and make him more human.
I'm further surpised that Philip Jose Farmer, the author of the Doc Savage biography, considers tales like "The Monsters", "Land of Always-Night" and "The Red Terrors" to be fictional and to not really have happened in the Doc continuity, but has no problem accepting "Resurrection Day" as canonical.
I hope I haven't given the impression that I don't like this novel. I do. But the outlandishness of the premise makes this tale a problematical one for any serious Doc fan or scholar.

- | - December 18, 2003 03:08 PM

Tim Lucas

This was the first Doc Savage novel I read. I found a shelf of maybe 20 Doc paperbacks for sale in a used bookstore and was inspired to take them all home. As I perused the plots on the back covers, looking for a place to start, this is the one that said to me "Read me first!" I was attracted to the premise -- "If you could bring anyone back to life from human history, whom would you choose?" -- which is quite arresting and signals a magical work of fiction. Trouble is, Doc's choice was not mine, and in this, I came away feeling as though I had made a more intelligent selection than Doc -- and the reader should never be given the opportunity to feel superior to The Man of Bronze! Doc's choice of whom to resurrect was neither insightful or illuminating (it seemed based on nothing more than the cliché "the wisdom of Solomon", later the key initial in Captain Marvel's acronym SHAZAM) and the pay-off did not balance the inspiration of the concept. From what I remember of the book and what I have picked up since by reading other Doc books -- I would agree with the other commentators that the concept is essentially at odds with the universe described by these books and their characters. I enjoyed it, but it did not propel me to read others in the series right away, the way THE POLAR TREASURE did.

- | - October 7, 2004 03:21 PM

Paul Cook

This is one of my very favorite Doc Savage novels. All that's missing is a pretty girl. (It shares this in common with Land of Terror). It's a great conceit: bringing an ancient man of wisdom back to life. It also is one of the rare Doc Savage novels where Doc is shown being a doctor, a surgeon. I found the book fast-paced, the villains credible and the scenes in the Sudan (or was it Egypt?) very exciting, especially the rare thunderstorm at the end. I also think that this book appears just at a time when the series started to wear on Dent significantly. The adventures start to flag after this. There are some high spots--Repel, Ost, and Fortress of Solitude--but this is one of the best of this period.

- | - November 9, 2004 05:21 PM

Mark Carpenter

I'd make the case that "Resurrection Day" is one of the top three books in the entire series. The resurrection premise is fresh, original, and totally ingenious...and Dent knew it. He writes with a joy and excitement that's missing in most of the later Doc novels. The plot is tight and smart, the action serves the story (instead of the other way around) and Dent's descriptions of the Nubian desert are wonderfully detailed.
Like all the best Docs, it stands up well on its own and doesn't seem like just another installment in the series.

One of the very, very best.

- | - June 14, 2005 09:37 AM


   
   

editors Post a Comment editors
 
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Note: Your email and URL will not be published.





Keep Info?



Please note: DocSavage.Org will never republish any comments for profit. We retain the right to edit or delete any comments. We also retain the right to reformat this site and any comments. By submitting your comment you agree to these conditions.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
   
   

Design adapted by: Chuck Welch and powered by Moveable Type
Send comments to: ds AT this domain

Patience and beauty by Catherine Lavallée-Welch

Thanks to Duane Spurlock at the Pulp Rack and Steve Sherman for their Bronzetoe help and inspiration.

Thanks to Chris Kalb and the 86th Floor for help and inspiration.

Doc Savage Org is a member of the Doc Savage Webring
<< Prev | Next >> | [ Random | Ring Hub | Join Us! ]


This page last updated at June 16, 2005 11:41 AM.

All copyrighted characters, names, and art depicted on this site are copyrighted by their various respective owners.

Doc Savage is (c) by Conde Nast
Bantam Scans donated by David Schneider.

DocSavage.Org is (c) 2004 by Chuck Welch Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.