Comments on: Doc Savage Was Born on… http://docsavage.org/2009/11/doc-savage-was-born-on/ A Hidalgo Trading Company/ Flearun Production Sat, 03 Dec 2011 00:47:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Doctorwholittle http://docsavage.org/2009/11/doc-savage-was-born-on/#comment-1182 Doctorwholittle Mon, 31 Oct 2011 03:38:00 +0000 http://www.docsavage.org/?p=1055#comment-1182 I've not read the Docs since forever ago (nor PJF's bio), but didn't it mention somewhere that Doc was 16 while in service during WW I?  That would've put his birth year anywhere between 1901 and 1902. I’ve not read the Docs since forever ago (nor PJF’s bio), but didn’t it mention somewhere that Doc was 16 while in service during WW I?  That would’ve put his birth year anywhere between 1901 and 1902.

]]> By: Chuck Welch http://docsavage.org/2009/11/doc-savage-was-born-on/#comment-1181 Chuck Welch Sun, 01 Aug 2010 14:29:22 +0000 http://www.docsavage.org/?p=1055#comment-1181 Jeff, nice to hear from you again. Odd, years ago when I published this...long before I published your article where you picked your own date....you didn't claim the research was shoddy. All discussion of a birth date is conjecture. You start with basic points and follow them to a logical conclusion. Of course, you're welcome to your opinion. However, if you think the research is "shoddy" please point out any misstatements or logical fallacies. Remember though, your own conjectures and leaps of faith are not arguments against my research. Jeff, nice to hear from you again. Odd, years ago when I published this…long before I published your article where you picked your own date….you didn’t claim the research was shoddy.

All discussion of a birth date is conjecture. You start with basic points and follow them to a logical conclusion.

Of course, you’re welcome to your opinion. However, if you think the research is “shoddy” please point out any misstatements or logical fallacies. Remember though, your own conjectures and leaps of faith are not arguments against my research.

]]> By: Jeff Deischer http://docsavage.org/2009/11/doc-savage-was-born-on/#comment-1180 Jeff Deischer Sat, 03 Apr 2010 18:46:16 +0000 http://www.docsavage.org/?p=1055#comment-1180 Shoddy research, I'm sorry to say. I prove in my own article "That Stormy Night" was born between late May and late July due to the midnight sun being visible near Greenland in Peril in the North. Also, Doc is far too young to have been born in 1901, as I explain in my chronology of the series, The Adventures of Doc Savage: a Definitive Chronology. Doc was born no earlier than 1905. Shoddy research, I’m sorry to say. I prove in my own article “That Stormy Night” was born between late May and late July due to the midnight sun being visible near Greenland in Peril in the North. Also, Doc is far too young to have been born in 1901, as I explain in my chronology of the series, The Adventures of Doc Savage: a Definitive Chronology. Doc was born no earlier than 1905.

]]> By: John Contreras http://docsavage.org/2009/11/doc-savage-was-born-on/#comment-1179 John Contreras Thu, 17 Dec 2009 03:03:09 +0000 http://www.docsavage.org/?p=1055#comment-1179 Well I for one live in Florida for the past 6 years and hurricane season dose not end till december..so you may be right..it is something for minds far greater then ours to ponder.Sincerely,John Contreras Well I for one live in Florida for the past 6 years and hurricane season dose not end till december..so you may be right..it is something for minds far greater then ours to ponder.Sincerely,John Contreras

]]> By: Julián Puga V. http://docsavage.org/2009/11/doc-savage-was-born-on/#comment-1178 Julián Puga V. Mon, 16 Nov 2009 22:29:34 +0000 http://www.docsavage.org/?p=1055#comment-1178 The Doc´s birthday date was (according my personal chronologycal study, see my aticle published on The Bronze Gazette # 56)May 25, 1901. JPV The Doc´s birthday date was (according my personal chronologycal study, see my aticle published on The Bronze Gazette # 56)May 25, 1901.

JPV

]]>